Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Amy Sullivan
REALTOR®
Cell: (717) 877-6726
Office: (717) 367-3500
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon YouTube Icon GoogleBusiness Icon Realtor.com Icon Zillow Icon Rate My Agent Icon VCard Icon 

Amy Sullivan's Customer Reviews:

  • 5 stars
    103
  • 4 stars
    2
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Amy Sullivan
(105 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 105 ratings.
105 user reviews.
testimonial quote

Had a great experience with my recent home purchase with the expert asistance of Amy Sullivan at Berkshire-Hathaway HomeServices. Amy was invaluable in steering us through the proces and kept me informed every step of the way. Thanks, Amy!

stevenmack00
testimonial quote

I would highly recommend Amy as your realtor She is very professional. She was very personable, stayed on top of things, communicated well and has a sweet personality.

Darlene Shuey
testimonial quote

As a real estate attorney with more than three decades of experience, I have worked with many real estate agents in my career. Amy is amongst the best in the business. Hard-working, experienced, detail oriented, calm under pressure, and joy to work with. We are repeat clients, and will not hesitate to use her again for our future real estate needs. Thank you, Amy, for another trouble free closing!

Eric Borgia
testimonial quote

Amy helped my wife and I purchase a home we can grow our family in for years to come! She is prompt, super organized, easy to work alongside, and works to get you the home of your dreams. When we had questions, Amy had answers. We are happy we chose her as our realtor and super excited to work with her as we try to sell our existing home! Thanks Amy!

Keith Brandt
testimonial quote

Amy was a wonderful realtor. She had our best interests in mind the entire way through the process. She was honest about the properties we looked at and helped us find the best fit for our family. Additionally, the other people we worked with at Berkshire Hathaway were all very friendly, prompt and professional. Extremely satisfied with our experience.

Luke Gawron
testimonial quote

Amy was nothing less than a rockstar. My wife and I switched realtors mid way through our home search and it was the best decision we made. She will absolutely jump through hoops for you when needed and go the extra mile. Amy is THE BEST OF THE BEST

Nabig Sakr
testimonial quote

She is amazing at helping us find our first home! She understood our needs and was willing to work with us within our budget and she works so hard to make sure we would find a home in the time frame. We appreciate everything she had done for us and we recommend working with her! She had our best interest at heart!

alyssa fernandez
testimonial quote

Great service got us 30 grand over asking pleasure and joy to work with! If selling house choose amy!

Jeff
testimonial quote

Amy was very friendly, wanted what was in our best interest, and was super informative throughout the whole process. Only reason why it’s not 5 star is because her house finding system would sometimes send us houses that were irrelevant. Otherwise, it was a wonderful experience and an easy closing process.

Ashley Danielson
testimonial quote

Amy was my realtor for my first time home buying experience and even though it was a long process due to the condition of the house that I wanted she never stopped helping me and advocating for me through the whole process. She stood by me every step of the way and I couldn't have asked for a better realtor. Would highly highly recommend anyone looking for a realtor to go to Amy.

Hannah Weaber
testimonial quote

Excellent experience.Would definitely contact Amy again for any future real estate transactions.

Merry Civello
testimonial quote

Mrs Emily Alison is 100% legit. She is a licensed trading expert I know. She will help you manage your account in fullness. I have try it and it worked out for me . I invested $2,000 and I earned great, as much as I got $18,000 in a week interval. I was excited when I saw such a huge money on my wallet. I thank God she did it, that I met Emily Alison ,you can reach her on Email: emilyalison691@gmail.com WhatsaApp: +1 (434) 373‑2110

Itz Samkelisiwe Mhlongo Mftœ
testimonial quote

Amy is nothing short of amazing! She stuck with us through 2 long years of searching for the perfect fit in a house. We were consistently in the know & almost always the first to see relevant properties. As a buyer in a seller's market, Amy is the one you want by your side through the process! She is a consumate professional, extremely knowledgeable as well as always quickly responsive. Thank you Amy for walking us through this process - your help was a gift and is very, very much appreciated.

Michelle Miller
testimonial quote

WOW, 25 showings in 4 four days! It’s all about marketing and Amy got it done!!

Ross Greenawalt
testimonial quote

Such a positive experience! And we found just the right house in a short time. I highly recommend her.

Rosemary Ford
testimonial quote

I've had the pleasure of meeting with Amy a few times over the past few weeks. She is an upmost professional at what she does. If you are looking at buying or selling a home look no further!

Joshua Choate
testimonial quote

Sold our home in three days. Offered great support prior to, during, and post sale.

Richard Hitz
testimonial quote

A my is both profesional and ethical. Not pushy ! keeping on top of details and communication I will use Amy in my future real estate needs Thank you Amy!

Josephine Diez
testimonial quote

Amy was awesome to deal with every step of the way. From the first phone call to the last handshake she was ready to answer any questions and offering to help with anything and everything. My wife and I will be more then happy to contact her again when we look at buying a house in the future and will keep her in mind for others doing the same.

Kevin Buesking
testimonial quote

I've moved a lot, and Amy is one of the very best realtors out there! She takes time to know your tastes and needs, offers professional advice, and advocates hard for her buyers.

Laurie Bergeron
testimonial quote

Amy was amazing to work with! She listened to the things that we wanted and helped us pick the right home! If there were questions that we had she would answer them right away.

Ali Burkhart
testimonial quote

Amy worked with us to sell our home and help us find a larger home that would fit our family well. She showed incredible patience with us and stuck with us, responding when ever we had questions about anything. She remained personable and professional through the entire process, and guided us the whole way. The personal touches she added just after settlement were proof that she is willing to go the extra mile. We highly recommend her services if you’re looking to buy and/or sell!

Allyson Cook
testimonial quote

We loved working with Amy, and she worked HARD at the end to pull it all together and see through not only the sale of our home, but the purchase and sale of our new home! She was responsive, professional, personable, friendly, helpful, and reassuring. She added personal touches at the end that were incredibly thoughtful.

Christopher M & Allyson C Cook
testimonial quote

Amy was responsive to all of our questions. She helped us understand information and walked us through the process and made sure we were getting what we wanted. She was patient when it took us some time to make decisions. Amy has answered questions and helped us even after we moved into our new house.

Ellen Zazulak & Zachary Shenk
testimonial quote

Amy is the best! I believe that buyers need to be realistic in their wants/desires so that they can give realistic input to the realtor. It saves both sides a good amount of time. I knew what I wanted and Amy provided listings that were on the mark for what I wanted and other listings that I should at least see or that were just outside my desired area. I liked her approach because I new I wouldn’t have buyers remorse after my home purchase. She’s very thorough. Ultimately I chose a home and later that night I told her that I had made my decision. What I didn’t expect was for her to contact the listing agent that same night to present my offer. Thankfully she did so because early the next morning another couple chose to make a bid on the same home. Her diligence paid off for me and I got the home of my dreams. I am grateful for her going the extra mile. Amy, best wishes for your future and THANKS again for your hard work! Regards, Jim Civello

James Civello
testimonial quote

I met Amy through my husband when he was looking for an investment property. I was impressed with her work ethic at that time. So when my mom decided to sell her home after having lived there for 50 years, I knew I could trust Amy to get the job done. This is a very emotional time and Amy supported us throughout the entire process. Her experience makes her very knowledgeable with all aspects of selling a home. She is extremely thorough and efficient, and she replies quickly to whenever you need to contact her. We had a few stumbles along the way. However, Amy guided us through all of them. She goes above and beyond to help her clients. I highly recommend her for all of your home buying/selling needs!!

Amy Matos
testimonial quote

Amy went above and beyond with helping us sell our home and purchase our new home! She helped us find exactly what we were looking for.

Mergler
testimonial quote

Amy is thorough, precise, and will make sure your home buying or selling is as streamlined as possible! She will go above and beyond to make sure you are satisfied. I've recommended Amy to half a dozen friends,family, and coworkers and they've all had great experiences!

Lauren Miller
testimonial quote

If you are looking for a realtor who does a great job Amy goes above and beyond . She sold our house with in 3 days. We can’t say enough great things about her she is honest and made selling our house a breeze.

Connie Grinestaff
testimonial quote

If you are looking for a reliable, local, and honest realtor, look no further. I was a first-time home buyer and Amy helped me find the perfect home! From the beginning Amy payed attention to my wants and needs of a home, and provided a bountiful of listings around the area. She stayed consistent and connected with me through the Pandemic and was determined to help me find what I wanted. Amy is reliable and walks you through the entire buying process of a home, and made it easy for me to understand. I highly recommend Amy Sullivan!

MaddieSchaffer7
testimonial quote

Amy was recommended to me by a family member and boy am I glad! She was so pleasant to work with. She was always realistic and genuine. Always looking out for what was best for us! Her communication was amazing! Very quick responses. We are so glad we got to work with Amy when we bought our first home!

zuser20171106010427626
testimonial quote

I met Amy in Feb 2020 at an open house. She was so helpful in walking me through the process of what it would take to sell my home and purchase a new one. She assisted in referring me to an agent for my home in Franklin County. She listened and was very flexible when my needs changed for the home I was looking for in this area.She was supportive and compassionate through the entire process. Amy helped ensure that both transactions were moving along and for that I am truly grateful. Because of her diligence and caring attitude, I am thoroughly enjoying my new home!

higginsfamily89
testimonial quote

As first time home buyers, we were recommended to work with Amy, and we couldn’t have chosen a better agent to work with! Amy was kind, patient, and shared our excitement every step of the way. She was very knowledgeable in the home buying process, and was incredibly helpful without being intimidating, which was a big plus since this was our first experience with buying! She walked us through each step of the process in detail and was always open for questions we may have had. We learned so much from her about what we needed to look for in a house within days! She was always available to reach out to and eager to find us the perfect home. We ended up getting the perfect house for us, all thanks to Amy and her direction. Would absolutely recommend using Amy as your agent!

arodriguez3113
testimonial quote

Amy was so much help when it came to helping me find my first home. She was very helpful to any questions that I had come across during the process as well as very patient. I would highly recommend her to anyone!

CassidyRyman
testimonial quote

After our first buyers backed out just before settlement our Realtor Amy Sullivan immediately got back to work! She immediately got our home back on the multi-list and several internet real estate sites. Because we had the home under contract and we were so close to closing we had moved out. Amy was very helpful in getting our house staged for sale. I believe this staging truly helped potential buyers see themselves living in the house. Once offers started to come in Amy was very helpful in getting the deal done and in getting us a good price for our home. Thank you Amy!

zuser20150705123146886
testimonial quote

Amy has been a pleasure to work with! Excellent communication from start to finish. She delivers on her promises, and is always willing to go the extra mile. Her level of professionalism made a tedious short sale experience worthwhile. I would recommend her anyone!

KatryceAllen
testimonial quote

Amy is amazing! She was so flexible with our schedules and helped us find our first home. As first time buyers, she helped us understand the process and really listened to what we were looking for. We have now been in our home for almost 2 years and we love living here! I would recommend Amy to anyone looking for a place to call home.

Cortni O'Hara Robinson
testimonial quote

Amy is amazing! She was so flexible with our schedules and helped us find our first home. As first time buyers, she helped us understand the process and really listened to what we were looking for. We have now been in our home for almost 2 years and we love living here! I would recommend Amy to anyone looking for a place to call home.

Cortni O'Hara Robinson
testimonial quote

As a first time home buyer, I had no idea what I was getting into. Amy was patient and always answered my questions, no matter how crazy I thought they were. She was always on top of what was happening. She was a pleasure to work with and made the home buying process enjoyable!

zuser20150710060352801
testimonial quote

Amy was so helpful in making selling our house as easy as possible . She was always available to us especially with our crazy schedules. I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home. Thanks again for everything Amy !!!

mmjneedham2019
testimonial quote

She was very helpful and patient. She help my parents find their house. She then helped me find my house. She made the process go very smoothly. And when I came to closing day there were no issues and it was very nice.

kristikimes3
testimonial quote

Amy was a pleasure to work with. She was also easy to contact and responded quickly to information requests, concerns, questions about township rules and regulations. I would reccomend Amy Sullivan to anyone who needs a realty professional.

dgrines81
testimonial quote

Amy was amazing throughout our home buying experience. She made herself available whenever we wanted to see a house. She even showed us a house on Halloween because we were going out of town and wanted to see it before we left. She was patient when we kept changing our mind about what we couldn't live without. In the end she helped us find the perfect fit. We would highly recommend Amy.

heathergriffin77
testimonial quote

Amy was fully prepared on her first visit. She had completely researched our property and came with a recommended marketing plan. She recommended a sale price that was exactly what it should have been. Amy immediately worked to sell our property, and it sold in 22 hours for more than listed. Her personal attention to our needs was outstanding. We recommend her without reservation. Wayne and Noreeta Martin

wcmncm
testimonial quote

Amy represented us on the buying and building of our new home and the selling of our old home. She was very helpful in setting a selling price for our old home which we sold in two days. She helped in negotiating a lease back on our old home as it sold so quickly, the new home was not scheduled for completion for two and a half months. Amy held our hand throughout the entire new construction project. The lot we discovered quite by accident had a small for sale sign with little other info posted. She researched the project and the developer and builder for us, and attended EVERY meeting we had throughout the discovery process, the negotiation and planning, and eventually the construction and move in. She even helped us with our downsizing in arranging for the donation and pick up of several rooms of furniture. She was on top of every detail throughout the process which lasted over a year from start to finish. We had never built a home before, so we relied on Amy to help us through the process. We certainly could not have had such a successful down sizing transition without Amy's help. She is professional, knowledgable, detail oriented, incredible on follow up, and just as pleasant a person as you could ever meet. We would recommend her without reservation.

rob shelton1950
testimonial quote

Amy did a wonderful job in helping us sell our home. She kept us informed and helped to make the process and transition seemless. She focused on our goals and exceeded our expectations. Thank you Amy

mwe3512
testimonial quote

Amy was the agent that I bought some neighboring vacant land from. She was very prompt and courteous from first contact to the closing. I would highly recommend her.

pbeachy1
testimonial quote

Patient, knowledgeable and very responsive In helping us find our new home in the perfect location! Amy really took the time to understand our situation, time frame and location desires and was professional throughout the process. We would recommend Amy to anyone looking to list their home or look for a home. We would definitely work with her again. -Steve & Michele

zuser20150705123146886
testimonial quote

We unexpectedly found a home we wanted to buy and we really weren’t ready to buy and also sell our current home. Amy was a rockstar helping us get through the process quickly and our home sold in 4 days! We still can’t believe we made it happen and we don’t know if it would have without Amy’s help!

beckynjon
testimonial quote

There aren't enough stars to rate Amy - If you look at the sky at night it would give you an idea of the professionalism and true client service I received working with her. From start to finish, Amy was always accessible, day or night. It's been 30 years since I've purchased a home and I had forgotten how nerve wracking it can be. Now that the kids are grown and have lives of their own it was time to "downsize" to a home that was smaller but also had the amenities I was looking for. As anyone who has purchased a home can testify, it is a roller coaster ride at times. Whenever I would become anxious, Amy would always say "We are going to find you a place that is a perfect fit!" Amy was very knowledgeable on every home/neighborhood we visited. Amy was 100% honest managing my expectations and finding me a home that was not only in my price range, but exceeded everything I was looking for. Amy had an answer for almost all of my questions and would seek answers if she didn't. Amy also went above and beyond and had a recommendation for every service I could have possibly needed (and the people he recommended were just as top notch). Amy also listed my old home and held my hand throughout the process: showings, how I should "stage" my house, what I should focus on, etc. I had a request for a showing 2 HOURS after she placed the for sale signs on my lawn. The first showing I had a great offer and accepted it the very next day. This Real Estate Professional really knows her stuff! The most important factor was that Amy made sure I knew she cared, was always honest and upfront with me and made sure that I had the best experience with minimal stress. She truly was invested in me and made sure I found my "dream" home. I will definitely be recommending Amy to all of my friends and co-workers should they need her services!! Amy — Thank you so much for helping me take this next step in my life - looking forward to a retirement in an absolutely beautiful home!!!!

zuser20150510085801905
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/11/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/11/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Mon 05/11/2026 1:12:53 AM EST) or Bright MLS (last updated Mon 05/11/2026 12:36:21 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
Federal Housing Equal Opportunity Realtor
Corporate Office - 215 S Centerville Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603
James J Hafer - West Virginia Broker of Record

©2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity.


Agent License Information: 
Licensed in Pennsylvania
Amy Sullivan 

950 North Hanover Street, Elizabethtown, PA 17022
717-367-3500

Login to Saved Search

Pixel